In an increasingly globalised world, online shopping has become a cornerstone of consumer behaviour. However, the complexities of international trade regulations, particularly those involving customs duties, have created significant challenges for both customers and businesses operating across borders. This article explores the negative impact of duty payments on returned items, focusing on non-EU businesses selling their products online to customers in the EU and UK. We'll delve into the intricacies of this issue, examine its effects on various stakeholders, and highlight examples from the fashion and premium product sectors.
Overview of EU and UK Customs Regulations
The European Union and the United Kingdom have implemented strict customs regulations to govern the import of goods from non-EU countries. These regulations require the payment of import duties, value-added tax (VAT), and in some cases, additional taxes on goods entering their territories. The rates vary depending on the type of product, its value, and its country of origin.
For example, clothing items imported into the EU are subject to duties ranging from 8% to 12%, while the UK applies similar rates. Additionally, VAT is charged at the standard rate of the importing country, which can be as high as 27% in some EU member states.
These regulations aim to protect domestic industries and generate revenue for governments. However, they also create complications for international e-commerce transactions, especially when it comes to returned items.
The Challenge of Duty Payments on Returned Items
When a customer in the EU or UK purchases a product from a non-EU retailer, they are typically required to pay import duties and taxes upon delivery. This process is often handled by the courier or postal service, which collects the fees from the customer before releasing the package. Or alternately, the fees are collected by the retailer and transferred to the logistics provider to ensure faster clearance and an improved customer experience.
The problem arises when a customer decides to return the item. In theory, these duties and taxes should be refunded. However, the reality is far more complex and often disadvantageous to both the customer and the retailer.
The process for reclaiming paid duties is often lengthy, complicated, and sometimes more expensive than the amount to be refunded. This is because it requires filing specific customs declarations and providing proof that the goods have been returned to the sender. Normally, the customer as the importer or the logistics provider, which originally effected the import clearance, can then apply for a refund but many customers find this process too cumbersome and end up not pursuing a refund at all.
The Impact on Customers
The impact on customers is multifaceted:
a) Financial burden: Customers may end up paying duties and taxes on items they ultimately don't keep, effectively losing money on returned purchases.
b) Deterrent to international shopping: The risk of non-refundable duties may discourage customers from shopping with non-EU retailers, limiting their choices and access to unique products.
c) Confusion and frustration: The complex process of reclaiming duties can lead to customer frustration and negatively impact their shopping experience.
d) Delayed refunds: Even when refunds are processed, they can take weeks or months, leaving customers out of pocket for extended periods.
Impact on Non-EU Businesses
The challenges associated with duty payments on returns also significantly affect non-EU businesses:
a) Reduced sales: As customers become aware of the risks, they may be less likely to make purchases, leading to decreased sales for non-EU retailers.
b) Increased operational costs: Businesses may need to invest in additional resources to handle the complex return and refund processes.
c) Customer service issues: Dealing with dissatisfied customers who have lost money on duties can strain customer relationships and damage brand reputation.
d) Competitive disadvantage: Non-EU businesses may find it harder to compete with EU-based retailers who don't face these challenges.
Case Studies from Fashion and Premium Product Companies
Several high-profile companies in the fashion and premium product space have grappled with these issues:
a) Net-a-Porter: The luxury fashion retailer, based in the UK, has faced challenges selling to EU customers post-Brexit. They've had to implement complex systems to handle duty payments and returns, potentially impacting their competitiveness in the EU market.
b) Burberry: The British luxury fashion house has reported increased costs and complexity in serving EU customers due to new customs requirements. This has affected their direct-to-consumer online sales in the EU.
d) Farfetch: The global luxury fashion platform has had to navigate the complexities of cross-border returns and duty refunds, which could impact its attractiveness to both EU customers and non-EU sellers on its platform.
Potential Solutions and Future Outlook
Several potential solutions are being explored to address these challenges:
a) Simplified customs procedures: Governments could implement more streamlined processes for duty refunds on returned items – given they are generating significant revenues on returned non-claimed taxes we don’t see this happening quickly. .
b) Technology solutions: Advanced customs clearance systems could automate and expedite the refund process. These however would still require partners in market who can legally operate on a business’s behalf when dealing with tax and customs authorities.
c) Business adaptations: Some companies are considering setting up EU-based distribution centers to mitigate these issues for their European customers but this brings into play complex business set ups and significant tax, reporting, legal and operational costs.
d) Duty-paid DDP (Delivered Duty Paid) shipping: Some retailers are absorbing the cost of duties to provide a smoother experience for customers, though this can be financially challenging as the company needs to wear the Duty refund to the customer on Duty for returns which can end up being in the hundreds of thousands of dollars over time. .
e) Working with authorised partners who can manage and reclaim your VAT & Duty in these markets – Contact us to learn how we can help you implement this solution.
The future outlook depends largely on how governments and businesses adapt to these challenges. There's growing recognition of the need for more e-commerce-friendly customs procedures, which could lead to positive changes in the coming years. However, with EU and UK companies lobbying their governments for the implementation of Duties and tariffs on all products and not just for orders over 130EU & 150 pounds to combat the cheap imports coming in from some markets we do not see this issue being resolved in the short term.
In Closing
The issue of duty payments on returned items presents a significant challenge in the world of cross-border e-commerce. It impacts both customers and non-EU businesses, particularly in the fashion and premium product sectors. As international online shopping continues to grow, finding effective solutions to this problem will be crucial for maintaining a healthy and competitive global marketplace.
While progress is being made, it's clear that more work needs to be done to balance the needs of government revenue collection, consumer protection, and business facilitation. As the e-commerce landscape evolves, it's likely that we'll see further innovations and policy changes aimed at smoothing out these cross-border transactions and returns processes but in the short to medium term we advise companies to look at building a Duty, VAT and returns model that ensures neither their customers or the company is left out of pocket. Governments are already generating significant revenues from cross border ecommerce without getting to keep VAT & Duty that they are not entitled to.
Stephen Schwalger
Director The Byte Channel & partner in Sell To Europe collaborative.
Comments